College Football Saturday Week 12 Free Plays / Breakdowns & NFL Survivor Week 11 Strategy
The College Football season is winding down. Conference Championship berths are on the line and there is limited time to impress the CFB Playoff committee. We have some BEST BETS and breakdowns for today's Week 12 action.
Plus favorites continue to dominate in the NFL, so which one did Mackenzie Rivers and Dan Rivera decide to keep them alive another week in Survivor? The guys talk about their strategy for this week with so many double digit favorites and alot of premium teams already used.
🏈 COLLEGE FOOTBALL FREE PLAYS
Jake Novakovich Free Plays (2-2 last week — 29-18-1 YTD +8.9 Units) READ JAKES FULL FREE PLAY ARTICLE HERE
SMU at Notre Dame
7:30 p.m. ET · Notre Dame Stadium
Notre Dame FIRST HALF −10.5 −115, FanDuel
This is the bet I should have made last week.
SMU keeps falling behind early. The Mustangs trailed at halftime in three of their last four: 20-17 against Cal, 20-10 at Syracuse, and 42-0 against Wake Forest last week in a game they lost 49-7. Before that stretch they led Boston College and Virginia just 13-10 at the half at home, as favorites of 21.5 and 10.
Notre Dame, sixth in the playoff rankings, is the opposite. At home the Irish have led at halftime 42-0 over Rice, 17-10 over Michigan State, 37-0 over Stanford, 17-3 over Miami and 31-0 over Boston College — a lead of 14 or more at the break in four of five.
And the second half is where they stop. That 31-0 start against Boston College became a 10-7 second half. Buying the first half is how you own the part of Notre Dame that shows up.
History: SMU has been behind at halftime, or ahead by three or fewer, in five of its last six. Notre Dame has allowed three first-half points in its last two games.
Hawai'i at Nevada
10:30 p.m. ET · Mackay Stadium
Nevada −5.5 −110, Caesars
Under 40.5 −108, BetMGM
Hawai'i is a long way from home for this one. Kickoff in Reno is 7:30 local with a forecast of 32 degrees. Hawai'i's three coldest road kickoffs since 2015, all below 40 degrees, ended in losses by 38 at Utah State in 2017, by 24 at Wyoming in 2020 and by 45 at Utah State in 2024. They scored 17 points in those three games combined.
Points will be hard to come by either way. Hawai'i has scored 17 or fewer in seven of its 10 games, including 13 at home against North Dakota State last week. Nevada's last three games had combined scores of 27, 34 and 35.
History: Hawai'i games are 8-2 to the under this season, Nevada's are 7-3. From 2015 through 2025, Hawai'i went 23-37 against the number on the road. As a favorite this season Nevada is 3-1 against the number, allowing 13, 13 and 7 to UTEP, San José State and Northern Illinois in the three covers.
BETTOR DAY FOOTBALL SHOW
Scott Seidenberg, Steve Fezzik & AJ Hoffman broke down their favorite angles for today's games. Listen/Watch this weeks episode
LSU at Tennessee
3:30 p.m. ET · Neyland Stadium
Tennessee ML -105, DraftKings
AJ'S BEST BET IS THE VOLS
⭐ And the reason is a quote
Lane Kiffin stood in front of a microphone after the last game and said LSU would be better next year — because he'd have better players and a better roster.
⭐ "Can you imagine sitting in that locker room and going, we still have two games left? What a crazy thing to say before a season's over. After the season, maybe. But when you've still got two games left, to say next year we'll be better because I'll have better players? There is no way this team is going to be motivated."
Tennessee's side of it
| Points allowed, last two games | 13 total |
| SEC record | 5-2 |
| Last week | Held Texas A&M's Marcel Reed to roughly 70 passing yards |
And the stakes are the whole thing. Win out — Vanderbilt is the only thing left after this — and Tennessee reaches the SEC championship game, gets Georgia, and plays its way into the playoff. As AJ put it: "This is their entry ticket."
Colorado State at Fresno State
7:30 p.m. ET · Valley Children's Stadium
Over 65.5 -120, FanDuel
AJ Hoffman called it a square ball play and played it anyway, because of one thing:
⭐ "There's no limit to how bad this Colorado State defense is. This is the worst defense I have ever seen since I've been watching college football."
The evidence: Washington State — a team with one win — went in last week and ran at will. 58 carries. 535 yards on the ground.
And the kicker: Fresno State has already had five games this season play into the 60s, and none of them were against this.
Tennessee Tech at Mississippi State
1:00 p.m. ET · Davis Wade Stadium
Tennessee Tech +33.5 -110, DraftKings
AJ Hoffman: This isn't a bet on Tennessee Tech. It's a fade of Mississippi State.
The case has two parts. First, Mississippi State lost its starting quarterback to injury, and their season ended the moment he went down — another dream crusher. The quarterback play since has been the problem. Second, the Egg Bowl is next week.
⭐ "I can't imagine a world where Mississippi State players are excited to go out and play Tennessee Tech, or chase margin. I think they get a lead, get off the field, and get ready for the Egg Bowl. Thirty-five and a half, with the quarterback play they've had? No chance."
And to his credit, he disclosed exactly how much he knows about the other side: "This is me knowing very little about Tennessee Tech. I haven't watched a single Tennessee Tech game this year. I don't even know if they have video cameras at those games."
Scott's research filled it in
| Tennessee Tech | |
|---|---|
| Record | 9-2 |
| Total offense (FCS) | 34th — 394.7 yards/game |
| Offensive touchdowns | 46 |
Which, as Fezzik noted, means a 9-2 FCS playoff team gets Mississippi State as its Super Bowl.
⭐ And Fezzik's parting shot: "Put me down on the moneyline, a hundred to one. I've got to make my money back for the Purdue loss."
NFL SURVIVOR WEEK 11

Survived Week 10 with the Rams — another rocking chair, 34-6 over the Cardinals. (And a welcome exit from the Stafford business: "I'm glad we're off that bandwagon.")
| The state of the entry | |
|---|---|
| Last week | Rams — won by 28 |
| Teams already spent | Chiefs, Texans, Rams, Jaguars, Panthers and more |
| The looming problem | Week 12 requires TWO picks |
Mac's framing: they're running out of the best teams, and the rest of the season is going to require creative picks.But this is also the week they've been saving for — five double-digit favorites, and the two biggest are both 16.5.
🏈 THE BOARD
⭐ Bills −16.5 vs. Dolphins — THE OFFICIAL PICK
- Josh Allen is 8-0 straight up against Miami — though he's failed to cover four of those, going 3-4-1 ATS. "He's won all those games. That's the important thing for us."
- Miami is down to Kyle McCord in his second career start, with no weapons, no defensive tackles, and center Aaron Brewer in concussion protocol. "I just think they're out of players at this point"
- ⭐ Mac's angle on McCord is the sharpest read in the pod: the second start is the sweet spot. On a first start there's no tape, so a defense may underrate a new guy by reputation alone. Now there's tape on him and no track record of success. "Kind of the best of both worlds."
- Buffalo is without CB Christian Benford, and Dalton Kincaid likely sits — which reads as rest, getting him right for later
- 🚩 The recurring fear: the one Josh Allen disaster game. It cost them a deep run once laying 14.5 with Buffalo, and Week 3 this year against the Chargers produced about five turnovers — they covered anyway
- 🚩 Dan's second worry is effort, not talent. Kansas City is on deck Thanksgiving night. "My guess is they do just enough to win." The hope: a big lead, hearts ripped out, starters pulled mid-third
- Dan's turnover math: even if Miami goes up ten points off takeaways, Buffalo can come back — provided Allen and James Cook stay healthy, and the backup running back can absorb some of Cook's work
- Miami's last game is the tell: they probably should have beaten the Colts, got a pick-six, and still lost — the kicking game didn't show up
Chiefs −16.5 vs. Cardinals — the free square, if you still have them
- Tied with the Bills for the biggest favorite on the board — and Dan and Mac already used Kansas City
- Arizona is likely starting Josh Johnson, who is 40 years old, on roughly his twelfth or thirteenth team, and making roughly his twelfth or thirteenth career start. "He never plays, but he plays once a year per team."Third-stringer Carson Beck has back spasms
- Dan: "They can put up 28 without taking the Cardinals too seriously"
- ⭐ The timing argument: the Chiefs don't have many outs left and the schedule gets hard. They host New England in a few weeks, but Dan expects the Patriots to fall off by then. "It's kind of close to now or never"
Bears −11.5 vs. Saints — Mac's No. 1 pick coming in, and they're still holding
- New Orleans is missing their center and right tackle, and "they can't stop the run and they can't stop the tight end" — precisely the two things you don't want against Chicago. Dan sees a big Colston Loveland game
- Dan: "I think the Bears are going to name their score"
- Weather was flagged as a possible issue earlier in the week. As of recording, no concerns
- On the look-ahead worry — Chicago plays at Detroit the following Thursday — Dan isn't buying it: "Ben Johnson is not the type of coach to let up here." He could see starters pulled midway through the fourth for the short week
- ⭐ Why they're saving them: the Bears are at Miami in Week 14 (Dan corrected himself live from Week 12)with Thanksgiving extra rest — a better spot than this one
- Secondary reason to wait: the Saints are terrible but not mathematically dead, with Tampa the division favorite at 3-6
Broncos −10 vs. Raiders — the most future value on the board
- Shopping note: 9.5 at −120 on FanDuel, but 10 or 10.5 most places
- Mendoza was conservative in his debut — roughly four-and-change yards per attempt, cautious play-calling, a loss and a non-cover against Seattle. Mac's read: "Two steps back to take four steps forward, maybe next year" — and he thinks Seattle came out unprepared and then turned it on
- Low total, so Denver's offense doesn't have to do much. Mac likes this more than the Cowboys and about as much as the Bears
- Dan assumes Brock Bowers plays but is nowhere near 100% — "way more banged up" than advertised
- ⭐ The reason to hold: Denver has the most outs of any big favorite. The Raiders twice, hosting the Dolphins, and at the Jets. Three to four more usable spots
Cowboys −8/−8.5 vs. Titans — in consideration, but reserved for Thanksgiving
- Dan would be arguing for them if they weren't needed for Week 12A. The Cowboys' passing offense should eat; the Titans' pass defense can't stop them
- 🚩 But it's the Cowboys: "It'd be pretty on brand for them to struggle in this game." Dan could see Cam Ward doing just enough to win outright — higher variance, possibly a higher-scoring game, and he's not sure Dallas covers
- The defensive coordinator situation is worth watching: a new coach is calling the plays this week while the previous one still holds the title. Dan's hope is modest — "maybe this is all they need to go from abysmal to just bad" — and there is real talent on that side
- Tennessee has scored 23+ in four straight and has been going no-huddle — but no weapons, and they traded two of their better defensive players
- ⭐ Dan's advice for the many people who still hold Dallas: kick them to next week. Most entries still have them, since the first usable spot was the Eagles game around Week 5. He assumes Joe Milton starts for Tennessee in Week 12, not Cam Ward
🚩 Lions vs. Buccaneers — Mac's buyer beware
- Baker Mayfield "seems to be somewhat back" off the bye
- Tampa beat Detroit in an early game last season and was close in a playoff meeting — and their defense may have answers for Jared Goff
- Mac was shopping for a mid-tier NFL favorite for a betting rollover and passed on every one of them. He doesn't like these in-between numbers, Dallas included
⭐ The sharp alternative is: don't have one
- Mac's concept, and it's the best piece of process in the episode: "My sharp alternative isn't so much a play as a concept — don't be too creative this week."
- Don't reach for the Jaguars (much better at home than away, though decent on the road under Liam Coen)
- Don't reach for the Steelers — Aaron Rodgers is around 23rd in QBR, "nothing special"
- Dan was going to name the Steelers and then talked himself out of it: "The better sharp alternative was just not to have one. There's way too many options. You're just forcing it at this point"
- If you're genuinely desperate, Pittsburgh works — and Dan would be fine saving them, since they play the Ravens later and "the Ravens could keep falling off a cliff"
🚩 Bengals — Dan's buyer beware, and a schedule worth protecting
- They host the Colts in a couple of weeks: "as long as the weather holds up, they're probably putting up 35 to 40 in that game"
- Mac's schedule check is the argument: Saints next week, Browns after that, then the Chiefs (don't use them there), then the Panthers, then the Colts. "There's like four or five times we're going to be happy to have the Bengals"
- Dan's precedent: the Bears-hosting-Bucs spot a few weeks ago, where you were "buying the peak Bears" and had to sweat it anyway
- Verdict: they'll probably win. You're still forcing it
📌 The Pick
| The pick | Buffalo Bills −16.5 vs. Miami |
| The free square | Chiefs (if you still hold them) |
| Best teams to hold | Broncos (3-4 outs) · Bears (Week 14 at Miami) |
| Sharp alternative | None — deliberately |
| Buyer beware | Lions (Mac) · Bengals (Dan) |
Mac's closing logic: "Let's take the easy square. I won't be foolish enough to call it a free square, but it's the easiest square on the board available to us." Dan's version was blunter: "Let's get off this train."
📊 THE DATA BEHIND IT: FAVORITES ARE PRINTING
| Favorites, last two weeks | 25-5 SU |
| Favorites of 4+ points, last two weeks | 17-1 |
| Since 2023, after Week 9: a 4-point-or-greater favorite | wins 82% of the time, 54% ATS |
And the one 4-point favorite to lose was the Texans at Cleveland — which, as Mac noted, "Cleveland looks like a playoff team, so it wasn't really that shocking."
The corollary cuts both ways: if you've used the Bills already, this is still an unusually rich board.
⭐⭐ THE BIG IDEA: JUST FADE THE TANKERS TO THE FINISH
Mac's read on the league is the same one Bearman landed on Wednesday, arrived at independently.
⭐ "The league has just moved in a direction of the haves and the have-nots. The trade deadline has been pushed back. You see teams like the Colts completely punting on the season. And instead of going after teams that still think they're in it — we can just go fade Cardinals, fade Dolphins, fade Cardinals, fade Dolphins, pretty much the rest of the way."
He mapped the entire path out loud:
| Week | The fade |
|---|---|
| 12 | Commanders vs. Josh Johnson and the Cardinals |
| 13 | Broncos vs. the Dolphins |
| 14 | Bears at the Dolphins |
| 15 | Packers at the Dolphins |
| 16 | Saints vs. the Cardinals (if New Orleans is still fighting) |
| 17 | Raiders at the Cardinals |
The catch he flagged himself: using the Bills now costs them Bills-at-Dolphins in Week 17. But that trade-off leads directly to his best point of the episode.
⭐ On why you don't plan that far ahead
⭐ "If you're planning Survivor saying, okay, Week 17 I'm going to use this team, Week 18 I'm going to use this team — it's pretty hard to get to Week 17 with a survivor ticket. It's less than a one-percenter. You can't really plan for that. You've got to survive in advance every week."
And the philosophy underneath it, with a sports-analytics detour: Mac has always disagreed with the just-get-into-the-tournament theory in real sports — "I think you have to build your team for the playoffs." But Survivor is different:
"In Survivor, I do think it IS that way. Get to Week 17, Week 18, and then you're going to have a chance. You can't really plan for it at that point — but get into the tournament, and some of the time you're going to win it."
🗓️ WEEK 12 IS THE WALL — AND IT TAKES TWO
- Week 12A: the Cowboys, eight-point favorites against the Eagles on Thanksgiving. Settled
- Week 12B: the Giants at Indianapolis is the leader. Mac doesn't rate the Giants — "I don't think they're a top-fifteen team, maybe eighteen or nineteen" — but the opponent is the point
- ⭐ The Colts cut Daniel Jones, and Anthony Richardson gets his first start next week. Mac's read on Richardson: "You might throw some haymakers, you might have a puncher's chance — he could throw the ball real far, he can run real fast. I still think he probably loses his first game. If he survives the game."
- Dan is less sure the move helps: "I'm concerned that Shane Steichen knows what he's doing, and there's a reason he was not pulling Daniel Jones." His assessment of Richardson is unsparing — a quarterback who could barely complete half his passes when everything was going well — and "this offensive line is bad"
- Mac's theory on the release: "I don't think it's necessarily a football decision. It's just, I want to blow this up, I'm tired of looking at this man in my face." (The Colts' third-stringer behind Richardson is Notre Dame product Riley Leonard.)
- A short, early Thanksgiving-week pod is coming so you're covered for both picks
As always, lines change, shop around. Take advantage of our FREE Odds Page and for a FULL MARKET REPORT on every NFL Game, check our or NFL HQ, exclusively for Bettor Day Insider and Premium Members. Plus our College Football HQ has matchup analysis on every game, with links directly to the Trench Reports. See both tiers →
|
🍂 The Fall Special 🍂 $25 off your first month of Premium Every sport in season, every pick, every HQ. Your first month is $29.99 $54.99. Get Premium for $29.99 → |