Skip to content
 Michael Reaves / Getty Images

Week 12 Card: Four Games, Five Plays

(2-2 last week — 29-18-1 YTD +8.9 Units) Last week: Texas–LSU under 46.5 cashed when the game went 43, and Boston College +29.5 lost — Notre Dame won 41-7. Penn State covered −10.5 and the Arizona moneyline crashed and burned after a late Utah score.

That Boston College loss is worth a paragraph, because the idea was right and the bet was wrong. My case was that Notre Dame takes its foot off the gas with a big lead. They did — after leading 31-0 at the half, they outscored Boston College 10-7 the rest of the way. The problem is that the game was already decided by then. The letdown was real and it lived entirely in the second half, which is no use to you if you bought the full game.

You'll notice I've carded the corrected version of that bet below.


1. LSU at Tennessee

3:30 p.m. ET · Neyland Stadium

Under 46 -110, Fanatics

Tennessee is an under team, and it has become more of one since George MacIntyre replaced Faizon Brandon against Auburn on October 3. In the six games since, Tennessee and its opponents have combined for an average of 39.2 points, and only one of those games — a 27-24 loss at South Carolina — went over 46.5.

They've done it by slowing down. The Vols have used 29.3 seconds of clock per offensive play in that stretch, up from 25.7 before it. Last week at Texas A&M, MacIntyre threw 17 passes, Tennessee held the ball 42:11 and won 22-7.

The defense is doing its part: Alabama held to 10, Kentucky to 6, Texas A&M to 7 in three of the last four. And LSU's scoring has dried up — 13 against Alabama and 21 against Texas, their two lowest of the season, with Sam Leavitt throwing three interceptions against the Longhorns. Both of those games stayed under the total.

The quarterback, since the whole case is named after him. MacIntyre hurt his knee in that Texas A&M win, Heupel used two quarterbacks in the game, and on Monday he would only say MacIntyre "will continue to progress through the course of the week." The reporting since is that he isn't expected to miss time. So the thesis survives — but check the availability report before you fire, because if Brandon is back under center the six-game sample I just quoted no longer describes the offense you're betting on.

One more piece that helps me: Tennessee lost receiver Mike Matthews for the season in the same game.

History: Tennessee games are 8-2 to the under this season, and all six at Neyland Stadium have gone under.


2. SMU at Notre Dame

7:30 p.m. ET · Notre Dame Stadium

Notre Dame FIRST HALF −10.5  −115, FanDuel

This is the bet I should have made last week.

SMU keeps falling behind early. The Mustangs trailed at halftime in three of their last four: 20-17 against Cal, 20-10 at Syracuse, and 42-0 against Wake Forest last week in a game they lost 49-7. Before that stretch they led Boston College and Virginia just 13-10 at the half at home, as favorites of 21.5 and 10.

Notre Dame, sixth in the playoff rankings, is the opposite. At home the Irish have led at halftime 42-0 over Rice, 17-10 over Michigan State, 37-0 over Stanford, 17-3 over Miami and 31-0 over Boston College — a lead of 14 or more at the break in four of five.

And the second half is where they stop. That 31-0 start against Boston College became a 10-7 second half. Buying the first half is how you own the part of Notre Dame that shows up.

History: SMU has been behind at halftime, or ahead by three or fewer, in five of its last six. Notre Dame has allowed three first-half points in its last two games.


3. Colorado State at Fresno State

7:30 p.m. ET · Valley Children's Stadium

Over 65.5 -120, FanDuel

Colorado State has stopped almost nobody. The Rams allow 50.2 points a game against FBS teams and 8.6 yards per play, and seven of their nine FBS opponents have scored at least 41. The last two weeks were the worst of it: 64 points to Boise State, then 73 at Washington State.

And the one that isn't in the history block is the loudest of all. San Diego State and Colorado State played a 105-point game last month — I wrote it up in this column at the time, a total the books ran from 60.5 to 64.5 and still finished 40 points short. That is what this defense does to a number.

Fresno State scores at home: 49 against Sacramento State, 38 against Rice, 31 against Boise State, 38 against Oregon State — 39 a game, and all four went over the total. Colorado State should add its share, having scored 26 or more in six of nine FBS games.

History: Colorado State games are 9-1 to the over this season; the only under was a 31-14 loss at Utah State. Boise State won 64-38 against a 69.5 total; Washington State won 73-7 against a 64.5.


4. Hawai'i at Nevada

10:30 p.m. ET · Mackay Stadium

Nevada −5.5 −110, Caesars
Under 40.5 −108, BetMGM

Hawai'i is a long way from home for this one. Kickoff in Reno is 7:30 local with a forecast of 32 degrees. Hawai'i's three coldest road kickoffs since 2015, all below 40 degrees, ended in losses by 38 at Utah State in 2017, by 24 at Wyoming in 2020 and by 45 at Utah State in 2024. They scored 17 points in those three games combined.

Points will be hard to come by either way. Hawai'i has scored 17 or fewer in seven of its 10 games, including 13 at home against North Dakota State last week. Nevada's last three games had combined scores of 27, 34 and 35.

History: Hawai'i games are 8-2 to the under this season, Nevada's are 7-3. From 2015 through 2025, Hawai'i went 23-37 against the number on the road. As a favorite this season Nevada is 3-1 against the number, allowing 13, 13 and 7 to UTEP, San José State and Northern Illinois in the three covers.


Jake Novakovich is a contributor to Bettor Day. You can follow him on X @CashOnSaturdays. Lines move: re-check before you play. Check out our FREE ODDS PAGE


Our College Football HQ has full matchup details on every game. Advanced stats like EPA/Play, Success Rate & Points per Opportunity, with direct links to the Trench Report for each game. All our data & analysis is included with an Insider Membership. Premium adds the picks: every play from every Bettor Day contributor, in one dashboard.Compare tiers →

🍂 The Fall Special 🍂

$25 off your first month of Premium

Every sport in season, every pick, every HQ. Your first month is $29.99 $54.99.

Get Premium for $29.99 →

Bettor Day • Partner Offers
One Code. Every Offer.
Tap a link or use code BETTORDAY
Underdog
Play $10, Get $50
+ 5 Free Rips Packs (up to $750)
OG
Trade $25, Get $50
In Rewards • New users only
ProphetX
Trade $40, Get $40
Rebet
100% Purchase Match
Up to $100
Onyx Odds
Spend $10, Get 100
In Bonus Picks
21+ • New users only • Not available in all states • Terms apply. Promotional content; not a recommendation to trade. Trading and event contract trading involve risk, including total loss on positions, and may not be appropriate for all — consider your financial circumstances. Paid partnership with OG; trading derivatives involves risk; availability subject to jurisdictional limitations; see OG.com.