Skip to content
Steve Roberts-Imagn Images

NFL & CFB Weekend Looks/Futures & CBB Update

Scott Seidenberg and David Bearman talk about the weekend in the NFL and College Football with some early leans and plays and futures bets. Plus a check in on the early part of the College Basketball season.

CTA Image

Listen to today's Podcast episode and don't forget to subscribe!

Listen

🏈 FIVE DOUBLE-DIGIT FAVORITES: DON'T LAY THEM, DON'T TAKE THEM

Bearman's first move when he saw the card was to text friends and make them guess the spreads. The Dolphins and Cardinals numbers were predictable. What surprised him were the Bears at −10.5 over the Saints, and the Cowboys laying more than a touchdown to anyone — "I'm not sure I would lay a touchdown with the Cowboys over my son's seventh-grade flag football team."

But his conclusion on the two 16.5s is firm in both directions.

Bills −16.5 over Miami: Buffalo has won eleven straight at home against the Dolphins, who last won there in 2016.And he genuinely likes what Miami has been doing — the Lions game came down to a late field goal, they covered against the Colts, they were in the game against the Chiefs. "They're playing okay. They're just not talented enough to win these games." But: "I can't take it. Buffalo could win that game 30-10 without blinking."

Chiefs −16.5 over Arizona: "I'm not in the business of laying fifteen and a half or sixteen and a half. It doesn't matter how many times you have me on the show."

⭐ And the warning he wanted on the record: "There will be people who have no problem laying the fifteen and the sixteen and a half — maybe even tying them together in a moneyline parlay — and getting absolutely zero value out of it. I'm telling you not to do that."

⭐ So he found another way in: Chiefs–Cardinals UNDER 41.5

He grabbed it Monday morning, and the case is three-part.

1. Arizona's offense is the worst in football without Jacoby Brissett.

Last two games, with Minshew and Carson Beck
Total points9
Games over 200 yardsZero
Yards against the Rams123

"You could accidentally get 200 yards in the NFL."

2. Kansas City quietly has a top-ten defense. All the attention goes to Mahomes and the new weapons, but they're 3rd in the NFL in scoring defense, 8th in yards, 10th against the run and 12th against the pass.

3. ⭐ The Arrowhead under trend, which he's already played three times this season:

Last 10 Chiefs regular season home games9 unders
Last 1311 unders
This season3 of 4

The only exception was the strange shootout with the Colts in Week 2. The other three visitors scored 10, 6 and 12.Teams considerably better than Arizona are not scoring in Kansas City.

Scott's addition: a warm-weather dome team heading outdoors to Arrowhead with temperatures in the high 40s or low 50s.


📊 THE BETTORDAY LINE vs. THE MARKET

We publish our own number on every game through the week, built off our power rankings and stats. Here's how it compares on the five big favorites.

GameBettorDay LineMarketGap
Texans (Thursday)−9.63−12.5Market +2.9
Broncos−8.97−10Market +1.0
Bears−10.75−11.5Market +0.75
Chiefs−16.1−16Even
Bills−17.5−16.5Our number is HIGHER

Read that bottom row twice. We're well under the market on Houston and Denver — but on Buffalo we actually make the number bigger than the book does. So this isn't a blanket "the books are inflating everything" story.

Scott's honest assessment of where we might be wrong: on the games where we're well short, either we aren't rating the opponent as badly as the market is — or we aren't accounting for the tax the books are adding to discourage moneyline parlays.


⭐⭐ BEARMAN'S THESIS: THE NFL IS BECOMING BASEBALL

"I'm not sure we've seen a year in the last decade — because the NFL has been nothing but parity — where we've had really, really good 8-1 teams like the Bills and the Niners, AND really bad teams like Tennessee and Miami and Arizona."

The cause: a trade deadline that suddenly matters

For years the NFL deadline was an afterthought. Now it isn't — and Bearman's point is that people are celebrating it without noticing what it did.

⭐ "Slow your roll if you're excited about it. Arizona just tanked. Philadelphia just tanked. The Raiders tanked and went young. That's something you see in baseball — the Marlins trade away two starting pitchers so they can bring up a prospect. That's what the Raiders just did. Arizona just did it. They traded away their starters and brought up a prospect. And the Eagles: we've won a few Super Bowls, we're having a bad year with injuries, we'll trade our guys for draft picks. That's the Major League Baseball way."

He's careful about the comparison — the NFL has a salary cap and baseball doesn't, so the economics aren't the same. But: "You CAN compare, because the talent gap is getting closer to what we've seen in baseball than what we're used to in football."

⭐ And here's the structural evidence

A division champion is currently on pace to finish7-10
NFC teams likely to make the field with roughly five lossesFour
AFC playoff seeds available7
AFC teams currently over .5007
⭐ "It's almost over in the AFC, and we're in Week 11. The next team up is the Patriots — and the Patriots are done without a quarterback. Who below the current seven is going to sneak up there? The Raiders at 4-6? Nobody's putting their money on that. The AFC is settled. You can mess with the seedings, but you've got your seven teams. You haven't seen that in the NFL before."

If he's right, it reframes the rest of the season. The question stops being who makes it and becomes where they're seeded — which is where the actual betting value moves.


🏆 THE AFC NO. 1 SEED: BEARMAN TRADES JACKSONVILLE

Buffalo is 8-1. The Chiefs, Jaguars, Bengals and Broncos are all 7-2. And the Chiefs and Bills play each other Thanksgiving night.

Kalshi — AFC No. 1 seedYes
Bills42¢
Broncos19¢
Bengals17¢
Jaguars16¢ — $100 returns $565
Chiefs10¢

His reasoning, team by team

His trade: Jacksonville.

⭐ And Scott's structural point is the best argument for it

The Jaguars don't get to hand a rival a loss — the Chiefs play the Bills, the Broncos play the Bills on Christmas. But the flip side is the whole value:

"Because of that, they don't run the RISK of losing to one of those teams."

Bearman, more bluntly: "You get to play the Colts and the freaking Titans."


🔄 THE REVERSE QUESTION: WHO REPLACES THE STEELERS OR BROWNS?

Bearman doesn't believe in either team, and they currently hold the 6 and 7 seeds. So who's coming for them?

His survey comes up empty. New England is the closest, "but they just lost their quarterback and you really can't go there." Baltimore "just embarrassed themselves on Monday night." And the tanking list removes everybody else: Indianapolis, the Jets, the Chargers, Miami and Tennessee. The Raiders have a tough schedule, a rookie quarterback, and aren't good enough.

His verdict: "Welcome to the playoffs, Steelers and Browns."

⭐ Scott's one real path: the Houston Texans

Houston has the easiest remaining schedule of anyone on the outside — and they could realistically win out.

They'll be favored in essentially every game left: at the Steelers (maybe by a point), at the Eagles, at the Commanders, and home against the Titans, Colts and Ravens. Home against Jacksonville will be close. The only likely dog spot is at Green Bay on January 4th.

So: even losing to the Jaguars gets them to 10-7, and beating them puts 11-6 in play. The problem is the one Bearman identified: "They lose games they should win."

⭐ And the tiebreaker that may already have decided it

⭐ "Seven weeks from now you could say that Cleveland's double-digit rally over Houston decided the last playoff spot. Now you've got a tiebreaker — you blew a huge lead to a team you're competing with, you're two and a half games behind them, and you lost to them. That's going to be a tough one."

🏈 COLLEGE FOOTBALL SATURDAY

⭐ LSU at Tennessee — Bearman takes Tennessee at home

Scott's question was whether LSU quits. They lost to Texas on the final play, got housed by Alabama, and are out of the playoff with Tennessee and Arkansas left.

Bearman's answer is about incentives, and it's the sharpest read of the segment:

⭐ "In a vacuum, LSU's the more talented and probably better coached team. But we're not in a vacuum. LSU is a team of all hired guns — mercenaries, as they call them — and you saw it fall apart the last couple of weeks. I'm not sure there's much incentive left, because they're not making the playoff. I'm not sure these guys getting paid six million a year are going to play spoiler."

Tennessee has the opposite set of incentives: one of the best defenses in football, 5-2 in the SEC, and a live path — win out, reach the SEC championship game, get Georgia, and play their way into the playoff. "They're not winning any beauty pageant points. But they're winning."

And the home-field detail that matters: Knoxville is where Tennessee blew No. 3 Alabama out of the building. As Bearman notes, Alabama-versus-Tennessee is going to be the sticking point in the rankings for the rest of the year.

⭐ Georgia −16.5 at South Carolina — play the FIRST HALF

"That's a lot of points to lay. If there's a team you'd do it with, it's Georgia. But I'm going to play this in the first half."

The reason is a pattern, not a hunch:

⭐ "Georgia has gotten off to fast start after fast start after fast start. They've built leads all season long. They're averaging roughly a 21-0 lead on the season."

Their winning margins this year: 60, 50, 28, 28, 24, 35 and 27. The only tight games were Alabama (won by three), Auburn (lost by three), and Florida, which was only close at the very end. "This is a team that is just housing people."

That's the clean way to bet a 16.5-point favorite you believe in: take the half where their edge is concentrated and skip the garbage time.

Kentucky at Missouri — the playoff math doesn't work

Kentucky is 5-3 in the SEC and out of the championship game. Bearman's read: "Somebody with three losses from the SEC is getting in. I'm just not sure it's a team that lost by four touchdowns to Alabama, lost by four touchdowns to Tennessee, and lost at home to a Florida team people had left for dead."

He's fair about it — those are all ranked opponents. And beating Missouri and Louisville does get them to three losses. But: heading into the Florida loss they were the three-loss team sitting at No. 11, and now they'd need help.


🔭 WHO GETS IN FROM THE OUTSIDE?

BEARMAN SAYS OREGON

"They've played the tough part of their schedule. They can win out — and technically they can still make the Big Ten title game. A lot of things have to break their way."

The arguments for: no tough games left, and winning the Big Ten makes it automatic. The argument against: a backup quarterback, "which isn't going to help them in the eyes of the committee."

His aside on their preseason ranking is worth keeping: Oregon was top three to start the year, which "doesn't mean anything — other than the fact that a lot of people who think of themselves as smart media members had them highly ranked."

⭐ The Wake Forest problem, and the BYU irony

Bearman's hesitation on Wake Forest: "the committee sometimes forgets the ACC exists." They're destroying people — they beat SMU by nearly 50 — "but who are they destroying?"

Scott's specific objection is sharper: if Wake Forest wins out and then loses to Miami in the ACC championship game, both of their losses are to Miami — one in the regular season and one in the title game. Hard to argue an 11-2 team deserves in on that resume.

And he spotted the bid-steal scenario underneath it: if Miami loses that game instead, Wake Forest takes the auto bid and Miami gets in at large — two ACC teams in the field.

⭐ Bearman's counter, and the precedent cuts both ways

"They say they're not going to hold that second loss against you for playing the extra game. They didn't hold it against Alabama last year. But they DID hold it against BYU, who lost to Texas Tech twice."

And then the genuinely strange consequence:

⭐ "BYU could be one of those teams that plays their way in by NOT getting to the Big 12 title game. They lose the tiebreaker, don't make it, and because they have two losses they just sit there and watch everybody else lose — with a Notre Dame win on their schedule that could get them in. So it could be a situation, which will be remedied next year, where BYU gets in BECAUSE they didn't have to play in the Big 12 championship game."

That's the real indictment of the format: a team can be helped by being eliminated from its own conference title game.


🏆 THE HEISMAN RACE IS WIDE OPEN

Bearman's complaint is about who isn't getting attention:

⭐ Scott's case for Devon Dampier at +700

"You want to talk about a quarterback on the best team? We're going to have a quarterback on an undefeated Big 12 championship team that's going to be No. 2 in the nation, maybe even No. 1. Why isn't Devon Dampier the favorite?"

Bearman grants it: "He's as good as anybody. He's the quarterback of an undefeated No. 2 team. If they win the Big 12, he should get it."

The Carr vs. Dampier comparison

CJ CarrDevon Dampier
Completion %nearly identicalnearly identical
Passing yardswithin 100 yards of each other
Passing TDs2322
Interceptions28
Rushing TDs—9

Scott's read: the interception gap is real, but nine rushing touchdowns matter in a Heisman vote.


🏀 FEAST WEEK: FLORIDA–HOUSTON TONIGHT

No. 1 Florida won Tuesday at the Players Era in Las Vegas and gets Houston tonight — a rematch of last year's national championship game. (Scott had Houston in that title game. Bearman had a 22-to-1 Florida ticket, so he ended the night happy.)

His read on the Gators: "Florida's the best team in the country. They have an unbelievable front court — and if they get anything from their backcourt, they're going to be the best team in the country."

⭐ And Tuesday night proved the point about depth

Boogie Fland went down eight minutes into the game. Urban Klavžar came off the bench and scored 24 points to lead the team, playing 31 minutes. He was the SEC Sixth Man of the Year last season, and he'll have to start tonight.

⭐ "That's the difference with this Florida team. Not only do they have the best starting five in the country — they've got two or three guys off the bench who would start anywhere else."

Bearman has no problem with the Klavžar start: Florida will be favored and should win. (And if the bracket holds, he's hoping for Kansas in the final.)

His broader early-season read: "Florida's good, UConn's good, Duke is good — and that's exactly what we saw last year. It's the same teams reloading: Florida, Duke, UConn, Arizona, Houston. I'm still all in on Florida. They reloaded, kept their guys, got deep on the bench. But Duke is really good too."


📊 CBB HQ IS LIVE — AND THE FIRST HALF DATABASE IS ALREADY PRODUCING

Just like the NBA 1Q/1H databases and the NHL first period, College Basketball HQ now has a first half database.A few early nuggets:

TeamFirst half, this season
Oregon State5-0 to the OVER
High Point5-0 to the UNDER
Minnesota5-0 ATS
Central Connecticut0-4 ATS

You can search by team or by conference, and last season's numbers are loaded too — straight up, ATS and over/under records in the first half, plus first-half and full-game stats, filterable by home, away, conference and non-conference.


📅 Coming Up

Betting with Bearman: he's traveling to St. Louis today for the UFL draft, with Friday's card covering college football, the NFL, some NBA and hopefully college basketball. Raheem Palmer joins the podcast soon.

Betting with Bearman Prop It Like It's Hot newsletter is featured in our NFL Prop Shop on BettorDay.com every Sunday.

BettorDay Fall Special: $25 off your first month of Premium.

🍂 The Fall Special 🍂

$25 off your first month of Premium

Every sport in season, every pick, every HQ. Your first month is $29.99 $54.99.

Get Premium for $29.99 →

Bettor Day • Partner Offers
One Code. Every Offer.
Tap a link or use code BETTORDAY
Underdog
Play $10, Get $50
+ 5 Free Rips Packs (up to $750)
OG
Trade $25, Get $50
In Rewards • New users only
ProphetX
Trade $40, Get $40
Rebet
100% Purchase Match
Up to $100
Onyx Odds
Spend $10, Get 100
In Bonus Picks
21+ • New users only • Not available in all states • Terms apply. Promotional content; not a recommendation to trade. Trading and event contract trading involve risk, including total loss on positions, and may not be appropriate for all — consider your financial circumstances. Paid partnership with OG; trading derivatives involves risk; availability subject to jurisdictional limitations; see OG.com.