NFL Market Movement, Massive Point Spreads & NBA Immediate Revenge
Scott Seidenberg and Michael Fiddle recap MNF and talk about the massive point spreads in the NFL for week 11. Have the Sportsbooks had enough with the Favorites covering? Plus we have 2 immediate revenge spots in the NBA tonight, what's the betting angle?
Listen to today's Podcast episode and don't forget to subscribe!
⚡ CHARGERS 23, RAVENS 20
Zay Flowers fumbled on what was effectively Baltimore's last real drive, just before the two-minute warning. Los Angeles milked the clock, punted, and the Ravens got two plays.
⭐⭐ Why Fiddle bet it — and what he got wrong about his own process
His normal method, stated plainly: he de-vigs the closing line, compares it to the price he paid, and calculates his closing line value. That gives him what he calls a market-implied expected value — distinct from model-based EV, which doesn't care what the market does.
And he trusts it for a specific reason: by kickoff, essentially everything is known — injuries, betting information, coaches' quotes, whose planes got stuck in the FAA shutdown, who's getting usage, whether a team is leaning on the run. So the final line before kickoff is the best available representation of a true 50-50. It may look absurd in hindsight. In aggregate it's a good forecast.
Monday night was the exception, and here's why:
| Variables the market had to price | |
|---|---|
| Jacoby Brissett's first game with a new team since being traded | |
| A first-year head coach | |
| A first-year offensive coordinator | |
| No established coaching familiarity | |
| A pile of Chargers injuries |
His conclusion: "Everyone in market was probably scrambling for a number here." He priced the game closer to 3 — about 3.1 — had an edge on the Chargers, and bet it.
⭐ And then the self-criticism, which is the actually useful part
"I'm using hindsight — but why didn't I go way more? If I have an edge here AND I don't trust the market here, I should actually go way more than I normally would."
That's a real refinement to how most people size bets. The standard approach scales your wager to the size of your edge. Fiddle is arguing it should also scale to your confidence that the market has done its job. When the number is a genuine scramble — a traded quarterback, a first-year staff, an injury list nobody can model — the usual deference to the closing line doesn't apply, and that's precisely when you should press.
📋 The props cashed
Scott's Monday call was Mark Andrews and Zay Flowers, laddered, on the logic that Brissett throws downfield and did exactly that in Arizona — including against this same Chargers team in Week 1, when Trey McBride went off.
| Mark Andrews | 8 catches, 82 yards |
| Zay Flowers | 6 catches, 74 yards (plus the fumble) |
Mac was on the Chargers and the over. Both cashed. This Ravens offense is better with Brissett in it.
🏈 IS LAMAR JACKSON THE MOST VALUABLE PLAYER IN FOOTBALL?
Baltimore is 4-6, and the argument making the rounds is a good one. If value means the gap between what a team is with you and what it is without you, nobody comes close.
Scott's framing: every team declines without its quarterback. A mediocre team drops from a 7.5-win projection to 5.5 — fine. The Jets lose Geno Smith and go from bad to bad. But the Ravens went from a legitimate Super Bowl favorite to a team in the running for the No. 1 pick.
Fiddle's parallel: we saw Case Keenum step in for Caleb Williams in Chicago and look like prime Peyton Manning — which cuts Caleb Williams' MVP case, not Keenum's.
🎯 The Bengals are doing to Burrow what the Lions are doing to Gibbs
Scott connected two things, and Fiddle agreed immediately. A few weeks ago Fiddle argued the Lions are force-feeding Jahmyr Gibbs goal-line touches to win him Offensive Player of the Year. Now the Bengals look like they're doing the same thing for Burrow's MVP case:
- Cincinnati's pass rate over expected is the highest in the league
- They should be running the clock out in the fourth quarter, or sitting him up three scores
- Instead they're throwing for touchdowns
Fiddle traced the lineage back: this is what the Rams did with Stafford last season — fifteen touchdowns from the one-yard line, with a dominant goal-line run game sitting right there. "You're throwing Davante fade routes, and then it's third down and okay, Matthew, we'll hand it off." And with Gibbs it's two attempts, three attempts, maybe a fourth-down attempt — Gibbs, Gibbs, Gibbs and more Gibbs.
🩼 QUARTERBACK NEWS: ONE GOOD, ONE BAD
Geno Smith avoided a major ankle injury and has a chance to start Sunday against the Chargers.
Drake Maye did not. The Patriots fear a broken ankle and are concerned he could miss the rest of the season. The backup is Tommy DeVito. New England is 5-5, the eighth seed in the AFC, right behind the 6-4 Browns who hold the final wild card — and they're on a bye this week.
The Jimmy Garoppolo question
The name circulating is Garoppolo, who knows the Josh McDaniels offense. Fiddle is in favor:
"Jimmy G gets more hate than he deserves because he missed one throw in a Super Bowl. If he hits that throw he's a Super Bowl-winning quarterback and he's probably still in the league."
The fit is real: McDaniels is still the offensive coordinator, Vrabel runs a similar organizational structure, and the familiarity is there. "You can't realistically roll out Tommy DeVito when you're a .500 team hoping to be a wild card. You've got to try something."
⭐ And the market consequence, which is the part to act on
If Garoppolo signs, you'd see the projection models move New England — "it would either shorten as an underdog or lengthen as a favorite." Since the Patriots are on a bye, this is a Week 12 pricing question, which means there's time to get ahead of it.
🌊 THE SEAHAWKS FUTURE: SCOTT'S BET, AND FIDDLE AGREES
Seattle is 6-4, the eighth seed in the NFC, behind the 6-4 Packers who hold the last wild card. Mike Macdonald is hopeful Sam Darnold returns after this week's bye.
Scott's framework: four division winners, two wild cards out of the North, and the final spot goes to the Seahawks over the Rams and Packers. Kalshi has Seattle to make the playoffs at 55-56¢.
⭐ Fiddle's diagnosis of Darnold is the best analysis in the segment
He thinks the "maybe Drew Lock should be the starter" conversation has it backwards:
"It's not the offensive coordinator who left, and it's not that Darnold was fluky last year. It's a bit fluky THIS year — he's been playing through a lot of injuries. He got hurt in Week 1 against the Patriots, played through the hip thing very quickly, and now it's a rib thing."
And the reason Lock has looked fine isn't Lock:
- A strong organizational structure
- A running game that finally works — Charbonnet nearly hit 100 yards, Jadarian Price looked good
- They have a one-two punch at running back again after both backs spent time on IR, forcing them to trot out two backups. This was the team that ran the ball the most in the league last season
The defense is still stout. And on the Raiders rookie: "Mendoza looked great for one drive, maybe one quarter, and then looked like a rookie in his first game ever."
Fiddle's own position: "Anything but the Rams, please — I'm sitting on a Rams-not-to-make-the-playoffs at +400."
⭐⭐ WEEK 11: FIVE DOUBLE-DIGIT FAVORITES
The books have been getting hammered. Over the last two weeks, favorites are 24-5 straight up and 20-9 ATS.
So this week they made you pay for it.
| Game | The line | Fiddle's market rating |
|---|---|---|
| Bills over Dolphins | −16.5 | −15.2 |
| Chiefs over Cardinals | −16.5 | −14.4 |
| Texans over Colts | −11.5 | −9.5 |
| Bears over Saints | −11.5 | −9 |
| Broncos over Raiders | −10 | −10 |
| (borderline) Cowboys over Titans | −8.5 | −8.2 |
⭐ Five double-digit favorites is the most through eleven weeks since 2009.
What a market rating actually is, in Fiddle's words: algebraic proof, chain law, the transitive property — math terms for taking the price of previous games and using the result and score differential as a correction coefficient to price the next round.
And the table tells the story: every double-digit favorite except Denver is hanging further out than the rating supports. The Broncos and Cowboys are priced correctly.
Fiddle's read on why: "I almost think they're doing that to make the moneylines pricier — because moneylines and spreads are correlated prices." Inflate the spread and the moneyline goes with it.
But he won't pretend that makes the dogs playable: "I kept running into this issue of — this is pricey on the favorite, but I don't know if I want to back that underdog. So maybe it's situationally finding the right ones."
⭐⭐ And a warning against the obvious conclusion
Scott asked the natural question: is this the week the dogs finally hit? Fiddle pushed back hard, and this is the most important thing in the episode.
"There was a year two seasons ago where favorites dominated at an insane rate ALL SEASON LONG — I believe the second-highest rate of favorites covering and winning outright in NFL history, and easily the highest if you limit it to the legalization era."
The receipt: FanDuel reported a $300 million NFL loss that season, and the CEO called the results "transient" — meaning the house simply ran bad because favorites kept winning, for an entire year.
⭐ "There's a lot of talk about: well, this is the week the sharps win and all the public favorites get smooshed and the teasers stop working. No. There was a WHOLE SEASON where it happened. There's no instant regression thing happening here — there's just randomness. Too many people subscribe to 'that just happened, so therefore this happens next.' You've got to almost wash the previous results out. You can't over-index it."
⭐ FIDDLE'S PICK OF THE WEEK: JAGUARS −6 AT THE GIANTS
"The lone favorite that I have value on." His number is closer to 8; the line is 6.
The reason is personnel the market hasn't fully absorbed. Jordan Davis and Jessie Bates both came over at the deadline — and neither played in Jacksonville's first game after the trade. He expects both this week:
- Jordan Davis on the defensive line against Cam Skattebo
- Jessie Bates in the secondary against JJ McCarthy throwing to Malik Nabers — and the last one of those we saw was the interception that ended the Commanders game
The second component is the market rating itself: point differential drives the correction, and Jacksonville has been blowing teams out and covering every spread, including last week against Tennessee.
His careful framing, which is the honest version: he's not claiming the market missed these factors. "It's obviously factored in — but not factored in enough."
⛰️ 49ERS −3 OVER VIKINGS IN MEXICO CITY: THE ELEVATION PLAY
San Francisco went straight from their game in Dallas to Colorado Springs, where they're training all week at the Air Force Academy to acclimate to altitude before flying to Mexico City. The Vikings are practicing in Minnesota and then traveling.
⭐ The precedent: Shanahan did this exact thing in 2022 — the same Air Force Academy week before a Mexico City game. The 49ers beat the Cardinals 38-10 on November 21, 2022.
Fiddle thinks it's a bigger edge than the one everyone talked about in Australia: there, the conversation was all time zones and body clocks. Here it's shortness of breath, and there's no time zone component muddying it. His number is 2.8 — "but that doesn't factor in the travel advantage I think the 49ers have."
⭐ And the Jordan Addison injury matters in a specific way
Addison goes on IR, and Fiddle explained precisely why that's worse than it looks:
"The main thing with the 49ers defense is they like to keep everything in front of them. Addison is a speed guy who can take the top off a route. So you can try to keep Justin Jefferson in front of you, play zone against him, and make him find the gaps — but now you're out your deep threat, your field-stretching option."
And the counterweight he names: "The only potential antidote for a Flores defense is an incredibly smart Purdy and Shanahan system with a bevy of weapons to take what the defense gives you."
Verdict: "I think we're correctly priced, but there might be enough manual adjustments to back the 49ers."
Plus one more Scott flagged and Fiddle liked
Chargers −3 vs. the Jets. The line implies Geno Smith plays. If it's Cade Klubnik instead, this goes to something like −7.5. Fiddle's response: "You actually might make me go play some Chargers and look into this Geno Smith situation."
🏀 NBA: FIDDLE IS BUYING THE DIP ON CHARLOTTE
Lakers −7.5 vs. Hornets, with Los Angeles missing both Walker Kessler and Austin Reaves.
Scott asked whether Luka goes off again — he put up 40+ last time without Reaves. Fiddle's answer is more interesting than yes or no:
"He might score 40. But his statistical output relative to his PROP is probably more of an under look — because his prop line is elevated with no Reaves."
The matchup reasoning:
- Charlotte's whole system is winning the possession and rebounding battle — and the Lakers are without their best rebounder in this matchup in Walker Kessler
- Heavy on-ball pressure, showing you at half court, wearing the opponent down, low turnovers on offense
- They want to slow the game down, shoot threes, and win possessions
"So this isn't a great matchup for Luka despite his usage. His stats are going to come from usage, not efficiency."
His play: Hornets +7.5 and the moneyline. "Buy the dip on the Hornets and sell high on the Lakers. I don't think we're pricing the Reaves and Kessler injuries enough — wouldn't be surprised if this is 6.5 at tip, wouldn't even be surprised at 5.5."
⭐⭐ THE IMMEDIATE REVENGE ANGLE
The setup: two teams play, and then play each other again as their very next game, with nothing in between. It doesn't have to be the next night.
Scott's finding: the edge isn't on the full game. It's in the first quarter, because the team coming off the loss comes out hot against the same opponent.
| Sample | Full game | First quarter |
|---|---|---|
| This season | 1-5 SU, 2-4 ATS | 4-2 SU and ATS |
| Since the start of last season | 46.8% ATS | 54.3% ATS |
| 2024 season | 55.5% ATS | 55.5% ATS |
| Back to 2021 | 53.9% ATS | 56.3% ATS |
Tonight gives us two of them: Blazers at Timberwolves and Raptors vs. Knicks.
⭐ Fiddle's situational refinement — and where it went
On Portland he's in, with a rotation argument: if Robert Williams misses on the second night of a back-to-back, "I'd rather limit the rotation minutes he was expected to get — and that's less in the first quarter than later, because the starters get extended. So you're betting into the more Clingan-based lineups in the first quarter."
On Toronto he was skeptical, for a good reason: "The Knicks play Jalen Brunson the whole first quarter. Unless he's in foul trouble, that's just his rotation." So the trend may not apply, and narrowing the sample to Knicks games with this exact rotation, back-to-back, having won the first one leaves you with noise, not signal. His suggested adjustment: first half or full game Raptors instead, to get around the heavy Brunson minutes.
And then Scott pulled the actual numbers live
Knicks in the second game of these pairs, having won the first, since the start of 2025:
| First quarter | 6-7 SU and ATS |
| First half | 10-3 SU and ATS |
⭐ Which means the second quarter is where New York surges — so the first-half adjustment points the wrong way. Fiddle took it on the chin: "So I'm wrong." And then supplied the explanation: "Because they realize they've gotten behind and need to get their act together."
The 1Q and 1H splits for tonight, straight from the database
| Team | 1Q ATS | Split | 1H ATS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Knicks | 6-7 | 2-4 away | 6-6-1 |
| Raptors | 7-6 | 4-2 home | 6-7 |
| Timberwolves | 8-5 | 4-3 home | 9-4 |
| Blazers | 4-8 | 3-4 away | 7-5 |
🏀 COLLEGE BASKETBALL HQ IS LIVE
It launched yesterday — and you asked for the first half database, so it's in there.
All of last season's numbers are loaded. A fun one to start: the best first-half team in college basketball last season was St. John's at 29-5-3 SU. This season, through a very small sample, High Point is 5-0 in the Big South.
And a reminder of what the NBA first quarter and first half databases actually hold: straight-up record, over/under record, ATS record, race to 10, 15 and 20, who wins the opening tip, who scores first, which players scored that opening basket, and full team shooting stats.
All of it at BettorDay.com and in the Bettor Day mobile app for Insider and Premium members.
📅 Coming Up
Predicting Sports with Fiddle runs Wednesday, Friday and Saturday — mostly NBA during the week, back to NFL on Saturdays for the late-week spots, where he's hunting prediction market liquidity and looking for where a late sharp move is coming. @FiddlesPicks on X.
BettorDay Fall Special: $25 off your first month of Premium.
|
🍂 The Fall Special 🍂 $25 off your first month of Premium Every sport in season, every pick, every HQ. Your first month is $29.99 $54.99. Get Premium for $29.99 → |
